Nå har jeg samlet litt mer håndfaste data.
Jeg satte opp ping-monitor (Netwatch - RouterOS/Mikrotik) mot første hop (GET gateway) og lot den kjøre mens jeg var på jobb idag, resultatet er ikke positivt.
Netwatch ble konfigurert til å markere GET gateway som nede når 3x ping på rad (1sek timeout) ikke har svart, så når den i loggen skriver DOWN har det allerede gått 3 sek uten ping-svar.
De fleste dropouts varer i 5-20 sekunder, men også en god håndfull på 1-5 minutter - og her snakker vi bare om ~12 timer!
06:01:13 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
06:01:15 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
06:19:16 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
06:19:19 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
09:10:54 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
09:10:57 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
13:57:34 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
13:57:38 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
14:20:22 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
14:20:30 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
14:58:10 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
14:58:12 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:02:06 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:02:09 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:12:01 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:12:03 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:24:03 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:24:06 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:25:25 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:30:15 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:35:25 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:39:23 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:47:58 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:48:02 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:48:07 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:48:12 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
15:48:40 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
15:48:42 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:08:13 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:08:18 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:08:25 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:08:28 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:08:40 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:09:00 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:09:13 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:09:53 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:09:58 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:10:01 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:10:16 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:10:21 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:10:37 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:10:39 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:17:25 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:20:45 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:21:04 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:25:20 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:25:28 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:25:30 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:25:37 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:25:46 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:27:46 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:27:48 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:28:01 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:28:21 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:29:34 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:32:48 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:33:25 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:33:28 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:35:16 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:35:39 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:36:01 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:36:09 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:37:55 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:38:46 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:40:46 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:40:49 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:41:34 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:41:45 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:41:58 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:42:25 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:43:10 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:47:18 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:47:52 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:48:02 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:48:07 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:48:27 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:48:43 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:48:48 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
16:48:58 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
16:52:49 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:02:07 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:05:24 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:06:22 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:06:24 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:06:31 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:06:33 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:06:46 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:06:50 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:09:22 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:09:25 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:10:22 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:10:25 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:10:43 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:10:45 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:11:18 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:11:22 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:11:46 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:11:51 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:12:58 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:13:00 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:14:37 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:14:39 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:16:16 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:16:18 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:16:46 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:16:48 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:19:43 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:19:45 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:28:37 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:28:39 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:33:13 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:33:15 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:34:26 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:34:28 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:34:56 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:34:58 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:36:22 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:36:24 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:37:43 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:37:45 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:37:58 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:38:00 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:41:07 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:41:09 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:53:07 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:53:16 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:53:52 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:53:57 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
17:54:37 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
17:54:39 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
18:05:07 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
18:07:10 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
18:07:22 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
18:07:24 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
18:07:34 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
18:07:36 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
18:41:52 script,error DOWN: GET Gateway NOT responding to ICMP Ping
18:43:31 script,error UP: GET Gateway responding to ICMP Ping
Sitat av
Rosander
For din del TS, så kan problemet også være hos deg. Bruker du noe form for splitter ved coax uttaket?
Cat5 er dårlig skjermet, forsøk å bytte til cat6 for å eliminere støy (crosstalk).
Ingen splitter. Jeg fikk montøren til å fjerne splitteren som allerede fantes fra da kabelen ble lagt inn for 4 år siden, nettopp for å eliminere slike feil. Enden på coax ble terminert på nytt, i en veggboks på loftet hvor jeg har samlet alt teknisk.
CAT5-kabel fra GET modem til min router (hvor Netwatch kjører, se detaljer over i denne posten) er bare 1m lang, men når du sier det så skal jeg dobbelsjekke at den ikke ligger krøllet rundt coaxen (selv om jeg ville forventet Altibox-linja skulle hatt mye mer trøbbel av den typen; 20m med CAT5 fra loft til kjeller, forbi strømskap)
Sitat av
Rosander
Get har også mulighet til å sette linjen på overvåking, ring dem og forklar problemet og si at du sier opp dersom de ikke utvider angrefristen eller fikser problemet.
Det visste jeg ikke, takk for tips!
Sist endret av geirgp; 23. september 2019 kl. 19:24.
Grunn: Automatisk sammenslåing med etterfølgende innlegg.