Sitat av
slashdot
Eit snøskred (reelt eller innbilt) kan vere meir enn nok til å skremme personer til å forlate eit telt nær nakne. At nokon har kle fra andre kan jo tyde på at dei var på veg tilbake til teltet, det same peikar det at dei vart funne med avstand frå kvarandre. Ingenting i det du skriv er jo kritikk av Brian Dunning sin glimrande gjennomgang av saka. Så her verkar det som du insisterer på å halde på det paranormale trass i ein god del som peiker på at du neppe treng det for å forklare hendinga - og du bryt suverent med prinsippet bak Occams Razor, som strengt tatt er ei viareføring av logikk.
Så vidt jeg vet, ble det ikke funnet spor etter snøskred, noe som får meg til å tro at du bare slenger ut generelle påstaner i hytt og pine uten å ha belegg for det. Har du hold for teorien din om at de skal ha "innbilt" seg et snøskred ? Jeg tror du er på like tynn is som meg når du kommer med sånt vrøvl:
The condition of the tent when it was discovered indicated that it had not been impacted with any form of snow flow of sufficient strength to knock over the poles. Put another way – it had collapsed laterally not horizontally. This is clearly visible in the photographs.
An avalanche would have left “Flow” patterns and other “debris” distributed over a wide area. Neither of these indicators were ever found.
Dyatlov Pass - Vertical Tent Poles
An avalanche of sufficient strength to “sweep” four people into a ravine – beyond the tree line – some 1.5 kilometres from their tent should have produced two results. Firstly it would have caused far more serious and different injuries and secondly it would have damaged the tree line at the point of impact. Neither of these conditions were ever observed.
The "dangerous" conditions sometimes referred to by proponents of the avalanche theory were observed in April and May when the snow falls of winter were melting. During February, when the incident occurred, there were no such conditions. In addition, the so called conditions were observed in a different location with significantly steeper slopes and cornices.
An analysis of the terrain, the slope and the incline indicates that even if there could have been a “miraculous” avalanche, its trajectory would have bypassed the tent.
Dyatlov was an experienced skier and the much older Alexander Zolotarev was studying for his Masters Certificate in ski instruction and mountain hiking. Neither of these two men would have been foolish enough to allow the camp to be established anywhere in the path of a possible avalanche.
Sist endret av Balderac; 18. september 2011 kl. 21:37.